Suggestion Cleanup Thread

[Sire]

It's that time again. All suggestions will either be deleted or moved into an archived section If you believe you have a really good suggestion but are afraid it may not make it, create a backup and post it again to see people's opinions.

Of course, we will be using this handy list here.

Also note that the list shall remain archived as well, and a new list will take its place after the cleanup and possible new layout.

* * *

The main point of this thread is to vote for which ideas will stay for WFTO. Everyone here is tasked to go through the list and vote for the ideas that should be carried on to the new list. The votes shall be carried out exactly the same as the Test Realm poll.
Also note that when you vote, you vote for the idea AS IT CURRENTLY STANDS. It is possible for the idea to be suggested again and possibly be improved upon in the new list.

* * *

Traps:
Reaper Trap (2)

Creatures:

Archlich (3)
Ogre (3)
Succubus (2)
Gargoyle (1)
Grave Rider (1)
Werewolf/Lycan (1)
Zombie (1)
Mud Golem (1)
Elite Creatures (1)
Boss Creatures (1)
Revised Dark Knight (1)
Manticore (1)

Heroes:
Valkyrie (7)
Juggernaut (4)
Maiden (3)
Peasant (2)
Druid (1)

Neutrals:
Pixie (4)
Wyrm (3)
Slime (2)
Mercenaries (2)
Scorpion (1)
Gremlin (1)
Savage (1)
Behemoth (1)
Viking (1)
Roc (1)

Other:
Trophy Specials (1)
Conquer the Kingdom Mode (1)

Creature Spells:
Ice Block (1)
Ice Barrage (1)
Blizzard (1)


* * *

Me Votes:

Reaper Trap: A new trap and one of the better ones out of the list, probably should be transfered.
Pixie: It was worked on for quite some time and should make it into the new list. However, I am starting to have my doubts for some reason.
Archlich: A powerful undead creature. Sure, why not?
Valkyrie: What, I really enjoy my Valkyrie idea...
Maiden: A special supporting hero, she should make it into the new list.
Juggernaut: A tanking Knight, better than a Guard at any rate.
Scorpion: Scorpions are good. Impale animation!
Slime: Slowly but surely the slime moves and devours...

[Hapuga]

use a poll, sire.

[MeinCookie]

I vote:

CREATURES
Archlich ~ A great undead unit that seems really well developed.
Gargoyle ~ A unique blitzer styled against undead creatures as a whole.
Grave Rider ~ An melee support unit and, more importantly, an undead blocker with decent health.

HEROES
Valkyrie ~ Probably the best hero suggestion around.
Juggernaut ~ Goodly heroes need an OP unit that can be placed in numbers.

NEUTRALS
Gremlin ~ Annoying as hell, mechanical minded neutrals with a knack for survival.
Wyrm ~ Just is.
Savage ~ A decent flanker... god knows DK II needed one!

OTHER
Trophy Specials ~ They add a really great variety and strategic value as well as sense of reward without making a side OP.
Conquer the Kingdom Game-play Mode ~ An old idea (not originally mine) which just about everyone wanted...

[QwentyJ]

use a poll, sire.

Trouble is, there would be too many options for the poll to take. I'd agree though that in principal, we could have one thread polling which creatures we want to keep, another for heroes and neutral creatures, etc. This though is not such a bad idea, but it is determined by the number of people who will vote on it. I'm alreadyt under way on it.

[MeinCookie]

Keep things together is my opinion... no one wants to check 8 different threads not to mention misc stuff.

[Monsterbaby]

Maybe this shouldn't be done by voting, but actually deciding, since hardly anything gets decided around here. Suggestions should be picked out by reason, not by votes.

[Necror]

most of the monsters already exist
i vote for monsters invented by people on this forum

[Hapuga]

I agree. I dislike the whole idea of pulling HOMMIII monsters into WFTO

[Mothrayas]

Creatures:

-Pixie

Heroes:

-Maiden
-Valkyrie
-Juggernaut (Heavy Knight still sounds better, though)

Neutral:

-Behemoth


Those are about the only suggestions that are really worthy to get in, imo.

[Necror]

I rated all the ideas on the site
if you wanne rate them all to download the xls and place your score next to mine and reupload

if im missing stuff please add them and reupload

uch he doesn't want to upload xls files i'll just zip it