Where the f*** are Diablo 1 and 2? And Warcraft 2 and 3 for that matter. Those games are legends among legends. (Well the Diablo legacy at least.)
At the moment the games I play in order of how much is:
1. Diablo 1
2. Minecraft
3. Dungeon Keeper 1
4. Amnesia: The Dark Decent (For Let's Play purposes only though. That game is way to scary to play for fun. :P)
And overall the games I like most:
1. Diablo 1 (Really awesome game, if you like DK1 you should like this one too. It's a RPG though.)
2. Dungeon Keeper 1
3. Minecraft
4. Half Life 2
5. L4D
6. Warcraft 3
7. L4D
8. Diablo 2
9. L4D2
10. Portal
11. Warcraft 2
12. GTA 2
And those are the only games worth mentioning, most other games were just a single playthrough and were left to rot on my hdd.
I did play WoW a lot when it first came out, on private servers though cause I hate to pay. But the games I played most would be Warcraft 3, Diablo 2 and L4D
Games I can't wait for?
Elder Scrolls 5 (I played 4 but I could not get myself into it, it was mad fun though.), Diablo 3 (That shit is awesome, big fan of the legacy.) and I hope to one day lay my eyes on a Warcraft 4, untainted by WoW which is an abomination. It killed the lore and a whole bunch of other good things about the warcraft legacy. Dota also ruined Warcarft 3, it's a shame.